The Herald

Baboon feud heads for ConCourt

Neither activist nor farmer prepared to back down after animal trapping methods​ highlighted on social media

The battle over an Eastern Cape farm owner’s right to privacy and an animal activist’s freedom of expression, could soon be headed to the Constitutional Court.

Insurance broker and farm owner Herman Botha has instructed his lawyer to apply for leave to appeal against a recent judgment which dismissed an order by the high court in Gqeberha preventing conservationist Dr Bool Smuts from publishing his personal information.

While the high court sided with Botha, earlier in January the Supreme Court of Appeal set the interdict aside.

If leave to appeal is granted, Botha, who owns Varsfontein farm near Alicedale, will have the opportunity to approach the Constitutional Court in a final effort to have Smuts take down statements Botha claims are damaging his business and putting his personal safety, and the safety of his family, at risk.

The saga began in 2019 after a cyclist passing through Botha’s farm snapped a picture of a dead baboon and a porcupine in a cage, and sent it to Smuts.

Following some correspondence with Botha, Smuts took to his organisation’s Facebook page, Landmark Leopard & Predator Project — South Africa, and published the picture of the dead animals, calling the killing “utterly vile”.

Along with the picture, details of Botha’s farm, his Gqeberha-based business, his home address, contact details and a picture of him holding his then six-month-old daughter were shared.

This picture has since been removed.

Botha believes he did nothing wrong.

The animals in questions were causing damage to his livestock and property, and were captured and euthanised with the proper permits and protocols in place, as required by the department of economic development, environmental affairs and tourism, he said.

However, Botha maintains that the personal information posted online stretched far beyond what was necessary for the purposes of conservation and activism, and has caused him insurmountable damage.

“I get threatening calls and messages at all hours of the day, people telling me how they want to pay me a visit and how they want to put me in a cage.

“These people have my address and they know my business.

“My reputation as a successful businessman is on the line,” Botha said.

He said posting details about the dead animals and his farm was understandable, and that he supported activists who fought for animals’ rights.

“But posting my home address and a picture of my daughter is going too far.”

Businessman and farm owner Herman Botha
COURT BATTLE: Businessman and farm owner Herman Botha Picture: Supplied

Botha’s initial application in the high court for an interim interdict prohibiting Smuts and Landmark Leopard & Predator Project from publishing alleged defamatory statements about him was set aside earlier in January.

A full bench of the Supreme Court of Appeal unanimously found that the high court’s judgment — that Smuts should have “practised restraint” in sharing personal information along with his opinions — was incorrect.

“Public debate does not require politeness,” the latest judgment read.

“The public has the right to be informed about the humane or inhumane treatment of animals at Mr Botha’s farm.

“Members of the public have the freedom to decide which commercial enterprise they support and which they do not.

“That freedom of choice can only be exercised if activities happening at Mr Botha’s farm are laid bare for the public,” the judgment read.

Botha’s attorney, Darryl Vorster, said they had started the process to apply for leave to appeal against the judgment and were preparing for their appearance before the Constitutional Court.

“We agree that activists should have the right to freedom of expression.

“It is a fundamental law ingrained in our constitution.

“But there must be an allowance for freedom of expression without it violating someone else’s right to privacy,” Vorster said.

“Botha’s personal life, and his business interests outside his farm, have no bearing on the issues pertaining to the ethical treatment of animals, and a judgment such as this, that damages a person’s right to privacy, could be precedent-setting and a very slippery slope.”

Smuts said he was aware of Botha’s intentions to apply for leave to appeal against the latest judgment and they would be prepared should the matter reach the Constitutional Court.

“It is his full right, as it is anybody’s right, to appeal against any judgment provided he has leave to appeal.

“I applaud his right to justice and to use the full ambit of the courts.

“We will go wherever the matter leads us, and if that means going to the Constitutional Court, we are only too happy to participate in the matter.

“We believe this to be a fundamental constitutional issue.”

Smuts said his organisation stood by the statements and criticisms about the “barbaric and vile” actions that some people took against so-called damage-causing animals despite the allowances made for animal control measures as detailed in SA law.

However, he said their ethical views and standpoint against animal abuse should not be conflated with the ongoing matter pertaining to Botha and an activist’s right to freedom of expression.

“In our original posts we stated Mr Botha may have acted lawfully, even if it was ethically unjustified.

“But the matter in question now is about people trying to curtail our freedom of expressing our views related to animal abuse and related practices,” Smuts said.

Regarding the legality of catching and killing problem animals, wildlife management organisations and problem animal specialists all referred to the norms and standards for the management of damage-causing animals as detailed in the Biodiversity Act of 2004.

The Act states that trap cages may be used as long as they are big enough to contain the animal comfortably and not cause it any injury while trapped.

It must be covered with smooth mesh that is adequate to contain the animals, and, more specifically to baboons, the cage must also be equipped with a safety catch to prevent them from escaping.

The Act further states that control measures should be proportionate to the damage caused, and killing or “permanent removal from the system by euthanasia” is permitted.

Baboons are not a protected species and are widely considered to be a pest animal.

HeraldLIVE