The Herald

‘Police minister Bheki Cele has spat in ConCourt’s face’

Kawa outraged by failure to act against negligent officers who investigated horror rape

Rape survivor Andy Kawa in the Gqeberha high court at a previous appearance
ANOTHER DELAY: Rape survivor Andy Kawa in the Gqeberha high court at a previous appearance Picture: EUGENE COETZEE

While the Constitutional Court has ruled that the SA Police Services’ search and investigation into businesswoman Andy Kawa’s horror rape ordeal in 2010 was below par and subsequently negligent, the officers tasked with investigating the matter remain on the payroll with no steps taken against them.

When the EFF asked about the ConCourt ruling in the National Assembly recently, the top brass of the police remained adamant that officers had deployed all available resources to the matter, and that there had been no misconduct in probing Kawa’s case.

And while Kawa had hoped the ruling in her favour would help her in the healing process, she feels the police’s unwillingness to accept their mistakes will haunt not only her, but all victims of gender-based violence (GBV).

“The system is broken and it failed me repeatedly for the past 12 years,” Kawa said.

“The Constitutional Court proved that.

“But until the police are willing to admit their mistakes and take decisive steps to rectify the system, it will continue to fail all SA citizens.”

On the afternoon of December 9 2010, Kawa was abducted while walking along Kings Beach.

She was taken to the sand dunes by two assailants, who forced her to strip naked before blindfolding her and raping her repeatedly over a 16-hour period.

She managed to escape early the next morning and came across a group of joggers who took her to the Humewood police station.

Her uncle had reported her missing at about 7pm the previous night when she failed to return home.

Her car was discovered in the beach parking lot at 11.30pm but police failed to locate her.

Kawa instituted a R5.8m claim against police minister Bheki Cele, former Humewood station commander Brigadier Ronald Koll, Warrant Officer Matabata Madubedube and Sergeant Adine Solomon, claiming they had failed to investigate her case effectively.

The high court agreed with Kawa, while the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) differed by ruling that the police had done everything in their power, and there was no negligence on their part.

However, in a landmark ruling in April, ConCourt set aside the SCA ruling, and in a majority judgment found the police’s actions to be negligent.

In the National Assembly later in April, the EFF asked Cele if any action would be taken against the officers.

In a response signed by Cele and national police commissioner Fannie Masemola last week, they maintained there was no misconduct by the police, citing that the ConCourt ruling was not unanimous.

“The members of the SAPS were not relieved of their duties, as there was no misconduct committed in relation to the performance of their duties, and this is confirmed by the dissenting judgment of the Constitutional Court,” they say in their response.

“It must be noted that the judgment is not unanimously in favour of [Kawa] and that the dissenting judgment supports the efforts made by the SAPS to search for [Kawa] and investigate the case.”

They said the foot patrols, rescue dogs and aircrews deployed during the search had performed to the best of their abilities.

They said further that all those involved in the investigation of Kawa’s case “fulfilled their duties with diligence” and there was no basis to institute disciplinary action against them.

On Wednesday, an upset Kawa said: “The Constitutional Court is SA’s apex court.

“It’s beyond comprehension that a minister can publicly denounce this landmark judgment.”

She said rather than take heed of the judgment and implement changes to improve the fight against violent crime, Cele had turned a blind eye to the police’s shortcomings.

“With his comment Cele spat in ConCourt’s face, saying he will not respect the rule of law and will not reform the SAPS to be responsive to cases of rape and GBV, as it is working fine.

“This is totally in opposition to what President Cyril Ramaphosa promised the nation.”

Kawa said Cele had taken an oath to uphold the constitution.

She is still waiting for the second leg of her civil case — the amount to be paid in damages — to be finalised.

“My attorneys are working on it and will notify me when the process is ready to move forward,” Kawa said.

In the meantime, the National Assembly has passed the DNA Amendment Bill which, once assented to by the president, will make it obligatory for all violent offenders to submit DNA samples to be added to the convicted offenders’ database.

This means upon conviction, or while serving their sentence, a mouth swab will be taken so that their DNA can be captured and checked against samples taken from past crimes scenes.

This could link them to previous offences and lead to further convictions and the resolution of previously unsolved cases.

DA MP Andrew Whitfield said it had taken three years to get the bill to this point, and he believed it to be a big win for the SA criminal justice system.

Referring to a case like Kawa’s, Whitfield said the database could prove to be an incredibly powerful tool to assist in the investigation of unsolved cases.

“The size of the database will determine its effectiveness, and while we would have liked to see this bill be passed earlier, we are happy to see it come to fruition now.”

The history of the bill dates back to 2013 when it was first proposed and temporarily adopted in 2015.

However, the period of transition expired in 2017, leaving a five-year gap when DNA samples were not taken from offenders.

“This was truly unfortunate as more than 96,000 offenders were released from prison over that period and most of them never gave DNA samples.

“But this time the act will be amended permanently and we hope to see it bear fruit once it is assented by the president,” Whitfield said.

HeraldLIVE