He was part and parcel of the brazen daylight robbery of Le Bon Bakery which resulted in the death of four of his fellow robbers and a police officer, and for that Sibusiso Mchunu was convicted of all their murders.
Handing down judgment in the Gqeberha high court on Monday, judge Jannie Eksteen said in its totality, the evidence presented by the state had overwhelmingly proved Mchunu’s guilt.
Eksteen said the inescapable conclusion was that Mchunu, 26, had the foresight to know deaths were possible when he entered the Rose Street, Central, establishment on January 21 2019 with the intention to rob the business.
He was accordingly convicted on five counts of murder, one charge of attempted murder, six counts of kidnapping and two of robbery with aggravating circumstances.
He was acquitted on one charge of the illegal possession of a firearm and ammunition.
“[Mchunu] was an active participant,” Eksteen said.
The judge dismissed Mchunu’s defence that should the court find him to have been at the scene of the crime, that he had disassociated himself from the crimes after he left his father’s licensed firearm on top of a dough mixer and fled the scene.
Eksteen said all the robbers had acted in common purpose.
He further found the witnesses who testified to have seen Mchunu, who was dressed in black during the heist, were credible.
The judge accepted their evidence in this regard and dismissed Mchunu’s claimed that he was falsely identified.
Mchunu was arrested six days after the botched robbery when police found clothing matching that of a man seen in CCTV footage captured at the bakery in his bedroom at his family’s home in Algoa Park.
A bag containing cable ties, similar to the ones used to tie up the Le Bon staff, was found in a drawer in Mchunu’s bedroom.
During the trial, Mchunu had denied the items belonged to him, saying he had no knowledge of them.
“[Mchunu] did not make a good impression in the witness box.
“His evidence was not only unpersuasive but illogical,” Eksteen found.
The CCTV footage, which played a vital role during the trial, was accepted by Eksteen to be true and correct even though the time stamp on the footage lagged by 30 minutes.
In the footage, five men, including Mchunu, are seen entering the bakery just after 8am.
Within minutes, the bakery’s staff are tied up and their personal belongings taken.
A total R9,000 was taken from the safe.
During the robbery, a staff member managed to active a panic alarm.
Flying Squad members constables Dwayne Kemp and Musa Hans responded to the alarm.
Within minutes Kemp was shot and injured while four robbers — Pumlani Dladla, 27, Mandise Jizeli, 36, Phillip Mphumezi, 33, and Thandolwethu Mkatali, 28 — were shot by Hans.
They were all declared dead at the scene while Kemp succumbed to his injuries later in hospital.
Kemp’s wife, Candice, who attended much of the trial, said after Mchunu was convicted that she felt a sense of closure.
“I feel it was the right decision made by the judge.
“I can now feel I can start to put this behind me and move on with my life.
“[Dwayne] won’t be forgotten — I don’t go a single day where I don’t think about him,” she said.
Hans, who testified as a Section 204 witness during the trial, was exempt from prosecution for his role in the deaths of the four robbers.
Sentencing proceedings are expected to get under way on July 24.
HeraldLIVE