The Herald

Sentencing in Le Bon Bakery murder trial expected on Wednesday

Though he was not one of the shooters, convicted murderer Sibusiso Mchunu should be sentenced to life in prison for his role in a holdup at a Gqeberha bakery which culminated in a shoot-out that claimed the lives of a police officer and four robbers.

Sibusiso Mchunu in the witness stand of the Gqeberha high court during an earlier appearance
AWAITING SENTENCING: Sibusiso Mchunu in the witness stand of the Gqeberha high court during an earlier appearance Picture: DEVON KOEN

Though he was not one of the shooters, convicted murderer Sibusiso Mchunu should be sentenced to life in prison for his role in a holdup at a Gqeberha bakery which culminated in a shoot-out that claimed the lives of a police officer and four robbers.

State advocate Mujaahid Sandan made the submission during arguments in aggravation of sentence in the Gqeberha high court on Monday.

According to Sandan, the robbery at the bakery in Rose Street, Central, on January 21 2019 was motivated purely by greed and had left the family of slain police officer sergeant Dwayne Kemp traumatised.

Kemp was shot and critically wounded shortly after he and his partner, Constable Musa Hans, arrived at the scene in response to an alarm being activated at the premises at about 8am that day.

He later died of his injuries in hospital.

Mchunu, 28, had taken his father’s licensed firearm into the bakery, had tied up the bakery’s staff up with cable ties, helped ransack the establishment and take the personal belongings of the staff. 

“It is common cause that [Mchunu] did not have a firearm on him and that he did not shoot anyone but he was aware of what could happen,” Sandan said. 

Mchunu was the only survivor of a group of five men who attempted to rob the bakery. 

He had used his father’s car to drive Pumlani Dladla, 27, Mandise Jizeli, 36, Phillip Mphumezi, 33, and Thandolwethu Mkatali, 28 to the premises.

During the shoot-out between the robbers, Kemp and Hans, Mchunu managed to escape through an open back window and sped off to his Algoa Park home.

The R9,000 taken from the bakery’s safe was later recovered. 

Mchunu was convicted in February on five counts of murder, one of attempted murder, six of kidnapping and two counts of robbery with aggravating circumstances after judge Jannie Eksteen found that in its totality, the evidence presented by the state had overwhelmingly proved his guilt.

He was acquitted on one charge of illegal possession of a firearm and ammunition.

Eksteen dismissed Mchunu’s defence, that he had disassociated himself from the crimes when he fled the scene after he left his father’s licensed firearm on top of a dough mixer.

He was arrested six days after the robbery and has been in custody since. 

Arguing in mitigation of sentence, Mchunu’s lawyer, Zolile Ngqeza, asked the court for leniency, pointing to his client’s youthfulness at the time of the robbery, that he had no previous convictions and that he was not part of the actual shooting.

Eksteen is expected to hand down sentence on Wednesday.

HeraldLIVE