Allegations of a trial by ambush, discrepancies in a witness’s testimony and objectionable questioning by a prosecutor, marked the day on Wednesday in the trial of a decorated police officer facing charges of kidnapping and assault.
Months after he initially gave his evidence against Warrant Officer Severiano Blundin, alleged gangster Alvardo Francis stumbled through cross-examination by defence advocate Jason Thysse as his version of how he and two friends were allegedly abducted, tortured and beaten by Blundin was scrutinised.
Before Francis took to the stand, Thysse told the Gqeberha regional court he wished to place on record that the state was using “underhanded tactics” after he was given a statement by a state witness by prosecutor Phila Ndamse 30 minutes before court proceedings started.
According to Thysse, the statement did not form part of the docket.
“This is a trial by ambush. The state cannot hand this to me in this morning when the trial has already been going on for so long,” Thysse said.
Blundin handed himself over to the police in March 2022 after the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid) concluded its investigation against him, which started in 2019.
He was released on R1,500 bail shortly after and is still actively serving in the police.
At the start of his trial in November, he pleaded not guilty to three counts of kidnapping, one of torture, and a charge each of assault common and assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm.
According to the state, at about 8pm on March 15 2019 Francis, Sherwin Eckhard and Keanu Arends were unlawfully arrested and kidnapped near Antelope Crescent, Gelvandale.
According to Eckhard, he and his two friends were approached by Blundin and another unidentified policeman who demanded their cellphones while demanding to know where certain firearms were.
It is alleged Blundin and the unidentified policeman arrested them on the pretext that the anti-gang unit wanted to profile them and check whether they were wanted suspects.
According to court documents, the men were detained in a white BMW before being driven to the parking area of the Algoa Park police station.
There, they were allegedly assaulted and then driven around to different locations.
Black plastic bags were allegedly placed over their heads and their wrists bound with cable ties before they were eventually released.
Under cross-examination by Thysse, Francis admitted that they had willingly climbed into the vehicle driven by Blundin and had then been taken to the Algoa Park police station.
He claimed, however, that they had not had a choice in the matter.
“We were not forced [but] we could not have left. The only choice we had was to get into the vehicle,” Francis said.
Francis claimed that he had told Blundin, and an officer wearing a balaclava, that he had a gun hidden in a shoebox in the ceiling of his home.
According to Francis, he only said that so the police would take him to his house so that his family would know where he was.
Questioned again by Ndamse, it was brought to light that Blundin had reported a charge of intimidation against Francis, but further details were not given after Thysse objected to Ndamse leading new evidence.
It was not the first time Thysse objected to Ndamse’s line of questioning, with the court siding with the defence each time and warning Ndamse not to “take a second bite at the cherry”.
Francis and Eckhard have since instituted a R1.2m civil claim against the minister of police for unlawful detention and humiliation.
That matter is still proceeding.
The criminal trial continues.
HeraldLIVE