Back in the day, you would sound really smart in my circle of young friends if you used the word contradictions a lot in social conversations. It was at once a Marxian reference to the conflicts inherent in capitalist societies as it was a way of signalling a higher level of social consciousness among fellow activists. It was, however, also a lazy way of explaining away things you did not understand.
There’s a lot of contradictions going on right now. You can’t walk on the beach, but you can congregate in the malls. You can’t visit family in their homes, but you can assemble in restaurants. You can go to casinos but be damned if you go to church (thanks Joe Samuels). People are confused but also angry because they simply cannot make sense of these contradictions.
One of the more difficult contradictions to resolve concerns schools.
Public schools must close but private schools can stay open if they wish. The private schools took some heat recently when the reopening of schools was extended from January 29 to February 15 because of the spike in infections and the burden on the health system as a result of increased hospitalisations.
Many of the privates did not close and so our activist MEC for education in Gauteng paid a visit to some private schools to change their minds with an unconvincing narrative about the movement of people amid a pandemic; unconvincing, because the department would not have postponed reopening were it not for pressure from the unions and others.
In law or policy, private schools are not under the jurisdiction of government; these schools can open and close as they wish provided they cover the scheduled teaching days. After all, they pay their own way, and they write their own exams. Here’s the rub: for a nationalist government with strong centralist tendencies from its ideological past, it appears weak and ineffectual in the public mind when it cannot bring all schools to heel. It was not health concerns that took Gauteng education MEC Panyaza Lusufi to Helpmekaar College; it was about saving political face.
Private schools are already an annual embarrassment to government since their grade 12 exam results, mainly written under the authority of the IEB, are so much better than government-funded schools. Now this.
Private schools are going to come under increasing political heat in the coming years. The inequalities of wealth are too obvious, the differences in academic attainment too stark, the independence of decision-making too unsettling.
Last week I delivered a Summer School Lecture at UCT on our book about the admissions policies of elite schools. Towards the end of the question time a group of students made strident arguments for the nationalisation of private schools; they had clearly been thinking about this for a while and made their points firmly.
It was hard to believe that this admittedly small group of students could make the case for nationalisation given the situation we’re in as a result of the gross mismanagement of state-owned enterprises that has destroyed the social wellbeing and economic prospects of ordinary people.
Why would such an obviously irrational proposal even be made? Simple. It is the deep frustration with what is not working, the public schools for the majority of our children. Private schools are simply a convenient scapegoat for the failure of public schools.
I am a product of public schools. Our two children attended public schools as a matter of commitment. I work day and night to improve the state of our public schools. But I believe that parents should have the right to private schools (or for that matter, homeschooling) not only because such a choice is guaranteed in the constitution but because it is good for democracy that people can choose to send their children to different kinds of institutions.
There is nothing inevitable about private schools being super-wealthy, elite enclaves in the country. We have some excellent examples of independent schools that were not extravagant but led the way in opening their doors to all children, even during the apartheid years.
Schools like St Barnabas and Sacred Heart College were outstanding examples of progressive education in difficult times. And I reminded our students-for-nationalisation that it was church schools in Zimbabwe that provided the foundation for that country’s outstanding school system.
That said, I do think it is good politics on the part of private schools to reopen in tandem with public schools — not so much for health and safety reasons (the mitigation regimes at the privates are excellent) but for purposes of social solidarity in a pandemic. That kind of gesture would bode well for the future of private education.