The Herald

Failed leaders falling on their swords unheard of in Africa

Gqeberha-born and raised David Mason said as a child he would disassemble anything electronic and try to find new ways to use the components.

President Cyril Ramaphosa is yet to clear his name in the Phala Phala saga. File photo.
President Cyril Ramaphosa is yet to clear his name in the Phala Phala saga. File photo. President Cyril Ramaphosa is yet to clear his name in the Phala Phala saga. File photo. Picture: Sandile Ndlovu

On Sunday evening, as I listed to President Cyril Ramaphosa blowing a lot of air in one of his pointless and directionless addresses to the nation, I could not help but think about how African leaders are rewarded for failure and lack of accountability.

I found myself reflecting on the developments in the United Kingdom,  the fifth biggest economy in the world by gross domestic product, which has been faced with great turbulence.

The country has been a revolving door of prime ministers, with all prime ministers since 2016 being forced to resign from office.

The first of these, David Cameron, resigned after the referendum on whether the UK should remain a member of the European Union, known as Brexit, was passed.

Though he was criticised for holding the referendum, Cameron did not support it and had wanted the UK to remain in the EU, albeit a reformed one.

Just hours after the results of the referendum were announced, Cameron announced his resignation, stating that on account of his advocacy on behalf of remaining in the EU, he could not in all conscience lead the country’s next chapter.

He was succeeded by Theresa May, who was tasked with facilitating the withdrawal.

May’s own term of office was tumultuous and she survived two successive motions of no confidence.

She was subsequently forced to resign when the third of her draft withdrawal agreements was rejected by parliament.

 May was succeeded by Boris Johnson, who would ultimately succeed in withdrawing the UK from the EU.

Johnson’s downfall began during the Covid-19 pandemic when it emerged that government officials, including himself and his close associates, had attended social gatherings which breached pandemic regulations, a controversy known as “Partygate”.

Johnson was fixed penalty notice for this.

But it was ultimately his appointment of Chris Pincher, the former Conservative Party deputy chief whip who was faced with a slew of allegations of misconduct and sexual harassment, that marked the end for him.

Johnson had denied knowledge of the allegations — but later changed tune.

This led to the mass resignation of ministers in Johnson’s cabinet, on the grounds of having lost faith in him.

He was forced to resign shortly thereafter.

Johnson was succeeded by Liz Truss, who was elected amid a crippling cost-of-living and energy crisis precipitated by the Russo-Ukrainian war.

Immediately upon entering office, Truss’s government announced large-scale borrowing and various tax cuts in a mini budget that was widely criticised.

This led to financial instability, with the sterling falling to a record low against the US dollar.

In an attempt to arrest the decline and criticism against her government, Truss dismissed the chancellor of the exchequer, the country’s finance minister.

As with previous PMs, discontent and resignations by senior officials followed.

Truss was ultimately forced to resign — just 44 days into her term of office.

While the challenges of the UK paint a picture of a perennial crisis of governance confronting the country, they are also an illustration of how the country takes the issue of accountability very seriously.

All PMs were forced to resign following failures by their governments to deliver on a mandate given to them by their party and constituencies.

This practice is unheard of in Africa, where leaders remain in office in spite of monumental failures to deliver on a mandate.

African leaders account to no-one and are rewarded for failure.

Ramaphosa is an example of this. The man is a complete failure as a president.

Under his dismal leadership, the country is experiencing a cost-of-living crisis, a governance crisis, an economic crisis and an energy crisis.

He is embroiled in possible criminal activity pertaining to Phala Phala.

And yet, he still remains in office and will likely get a second term.

In the UK and in normal countries, such a travesty would not be permitted.

But in Africa, this is our normal.