The Gqeberha high court has ordered that the municipality’s decision to recommend Sime and Mzweida Trading as the successful bidder to host the Summer Season programme, be set aside and the tender process start afresh.
In addition, the Nelson Mandela Bay municipality was ordered to pay the costs of the court action.
The order comes after Darren Munger, of Lumigenix, which trades as Soul Good, took the municipality to court after his company lost the bid to host the event in 2021.
The municipality dismissed Soul Good’s bid for the multimillion-rand three-year tender, as the company allegedly failed to supply a certified BBBEE certificate in its tender pack.
On September 29 2021, the municipality’s bid adjudication committee (BAC) recommended that the tender be awarded to Qonce-based company, Sime and Mzweida Trading.
Mungur objected to the BAC’s recommendation but on November 24 2021, the tender objections committee dismissed his objection.
He then took the matter to court, seeking an urgent interdict to stop the tender from proceeding any further.
However, before that matter could be dealt with in court the municipality announced that it would not allow any large gatherings or festivals due to a resurgence of Covid-19.
In January, Mungur went back to court, this time to ask that the tender adjudication process which saw Sime and Mzweida recommended, be reviewed and set aside.
In court papers Mungur claimed that the decision by the municipality to award Sime and Mzweida the tender was influenced by irrelevant factors, that his bid-pack had been “disassembled” and essential items were removed, including the BBBEE certificate and that the decision to dismiss Soul Good was “induced by fraud and/or deliberate error”, among others.
Mungur said in his affidavit that it was clear that someone had sought to undermine the bid evaluation and adjudication process to propagate a dishonestly awarded tender to Sime and Mzweida.
In a second affidavit Mungur claimed municipal officials had deliberately removed Soul Goods certification and that it was evident there was outside interference with his bid pack.
Mungur said this was evident in the fact that the boxes used to tick if relevant documentation was received by the tender committee had been completed and showed that the certificate was present at the time.
This was an essential component for the evaluation of the tender invitation and was something that was done by municipal officials, Mungur said.
The document was presented to Mungur’s legal team by the municipality during the discovery of documents phase.
Court documents showed that Sime and Mzweida did not have proof that its municipal rates and taxes were in good standing with the Nelson Mandela Bay municipality, where the event was to be held, which was a prerequisite as per the tender invitation.
On Tuesday the court ordered that any contract or service level agreement, if applicable, concluded between the metro and Sime and Mzweida Trading, be rescinded and set aside.
It was further ordered that Soul Good be awarded the costs of both applications.
The court order was signed by the registrar of the high court exactly one year after the tender objections committee dismissed Mungur’s objection.
Municipal spokesperson Sithembiso Soyaya previously confirmed that the city would not host a summer season programme in 2022 as there was no service provider in place.
Attorney Dean Murray, who acted on behalf of Mungur, said: “We are happy with the outcome as it is what we requested in our application.”
HeraldLIVE