An application for the magistrate to call the investigating officer to the stand to give further insight into the investigation of the kidnapping of Bay biokineticist Riana Pretorius was dismissed in the Gqeberha magistrate’s court on Friday.
The application was filed on Wednesday after state prosecutor Benedict Wilson read an affidavit by investigating officer Colonel Kanna Swanepoel into the record as the state opposed the bail applications of alleged kidnappers Xolisile Rawutini and Xolani Kafile.
Kafile’s attorney, Wayne MacGear, said the state’s bold allegations against his client were unsubstantiated and the magistrate could not make a fair judgment based on the limited information before the court.
Swanepoel’s statement summarised the events of March 16, and the days that followed, when Pretorius, 26, was kidnapped at gunpoint from her place of work in Newton Park and held captive for eight days before a ransom of R1.1m was paid and she was released.
Rawutini was arrested minutes after the kidnapping, with the Toyota Corolla, used in the abduction.
Kafile was arrested a few days after Pretorius’s release.
Forensic services allegedly found his palm print on the Toyota Corolla and found him in possession of cash with the same serial numbers and fluorescent dye on the money used to pay the ransom.
In response to MacGear’s application, Wilson said he believed this was a veiled attempt by the defence to question the investigating officer before the trial, and said the defence was in no position to dictate to the court that the investigating officer should give verbal testimony.
Wilson also referred to cases in the past where magistrates overstepped their obligation, and rather than ask for clarity on evidence led before the court, started their own interrogation of witnesses by acting “investigatory and inquisitively”.
Magistrate Thembakazi Mlindazwe dismissed the application “by virtue of it being flawed”, saying there was enough information for her to make a decision.
She also said it would be unfair to expect the investigating officer to give verbal testimony, while both accused were allowed to submit affidavits as evidence.
The defence attorneys then continued with their closing arguments in the bail proceedings.
Attorney Bond Nyoka, on behalf of Rawutini, maintained his client’s innocence in the matter.
He said the only reason his client had been with the suspicious car was that he operated as a jikeleza driver, and an acquaintance had asked him to take the car to fetch someone from the Greenacres Shopping Centre.
When a pursuit ensued, Rawutini fled, thinking the car behind him could be someone from the taxi industry who wanted to stop his jikeleza operations, or it could be people posing as police and meaning him harm.
He claimed to have no involvement, or even knowledge, of Pretorius’s kidnapping.
Similarly, MacGear, on behalf of Kafile, argued his client’s innocence — he had not been in Gqeberha on the day of the kidnapping.
He maintained that there was not enough evidence before the court on how Kafile’s palm print came to be on the kidnapping vehicle, and how his client came into possession of the alleged ransom money.
MacGear said the state was “clutching at straws” and the case against his client was not nearly as strong as the prosecution wanted the court to believe.
HeraldLIVE